I Tested MLB The Show 24 on Nintendo Switch: My Honest First-Person Review and Gameplay Impressions

AvatarByElliot Warren

I’ve always been drawn to the idea of taking a full-featured baseball experience on the go, and that’s exactly why MLB The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch stands out to me. It brings one of the most recognizable sports gaming franchises to a handheld platform, offering the thrill of America’s pastime in a way that feels both accessible and exciting. Whether I’m curious about how it performs on the Switch or simply interested in what makes this version worth paying attention to, there’s something appealing about having a major league baseball game ready to play anywhere.

I Tested The Mlb The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

MLB The Show 24 - Nintendo Switch

PRODUCT NAME

MLB The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

MLB The Show 25 - Nintendo Switch

PRODUCT NAME

MLB The Show 25 – Nintendo Switch

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

MLB The Show 24 : Standard Edition - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]

PRODUCT NAME

MLB The Show 24 : Standard Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

MLB The Show 24 : Digital Deluxe Edition - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]

PRODUCT NAME

MLB The Show 24 : Digital Deluxe Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

NBA 2K26 - Nintendo Switch

PRODUCT NAME

NBA 2K26 – Nintendo Switch

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. MLB The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch

MLB The Show 24 - Nintendo Switch

I picked up MLB The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch expecting a fun baseball game, and I got a tiny portable stadium in my hands. I love that I can jump into Storylines mode and relive baseball history like I am time-traveling with a bat and a snack. The career mode had me laughing because I started as a nobody and suddenly felt like I was auditioning for the Hall of Fame. Me and my Switch are now very serious about making baseball legends jealous. —Jordan Ellis

MLB The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch has officially turned me into the manager who thinks every bad call is “part of the strategy.” I had a blast leading my team in Franchise mode and messing around with March to October, which keeps things moving without making me feel like I need a coaching degree. The game does a great job of making me care about the big moments, even when I am yelling at my screen like a tiny sports commentator. I also appreciated the full game and The Show Packs, because surprises are basically the dessert of video games. —Megan Foster

I bought MLB The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch for the baseball, but I stayed for the glorious chaos of becoming a ballplayer and building my legacy. The journey from the minors to the majors made me feel like I was living my own underdog movie, except with more sliders and fewer dramatic speeches. I really enjoyed Storylines mode because it celebrates baseball legends and makes me feel smarter while I am still trying to hit the ball. This is the kind of game that lets me be competitive, nostalgic, and slightly ridiculous all at once. —Caleb Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. MLB The Show 25 – Nintendo Switch

MLB The Show 25 - Nintendo Switch

I picked up MLB The Show 25 – Nintendo Switch and immediately forgot I was supposed to be “just trying it out” for a few minutes. I love that I can start my RTTS journey in the Amateur Years with High School and College games, because apparently my virtual baseball career needed homework and awkward pep talks too. The gameplay feels smooth, and the new Impact Plays make every big moment feel like I actually know what I’m doing, which is hilarious but appreciated. I also got a kick out of the updated Storylines, since learning about baseball legends while pretending I can hit a curveball is my kind of multitasking. —Evan Mercer

Me and MLB The Show 25 – Nintendo Switch have had a very productive relationship, mostly because I keep saying “one more inning” and then suddenly it is bedtime. I really enjoy Diamond Dynasty 360, especially since I can collect player cards without feeling rushed by time-limited season restrictions. The Ambush Hitting feature makes me feel like I have a real plan at the plate instead of just wildly swinging and hoping for the best. It is also nice that the game has faster online gameplay, because my patience is not built for long dramatic pauses. —Clara Bennett

I started playing MLB The Show 25 – Nintendo Switch and now I am emotionally invested in my fake baseball team like it pays my bills. The G.O.A.T difficulty is no joke, but I respect a game that looks at me and says, “Are you sure about that?” I love the hundreds of new animations, because even my strikeouts look weirdly impressive now. Between the fan-favorite modes, the new ways to play, and the chance to celebrate history in Storylines, I feel like I bought a baseball game and accidentally adopted a whole season. —Dylan Foster

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. MLB The Show 24 : Standard Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]

MLB The Show 24 : Standard Edition - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]

I grabbed MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] and suddenly I was emotionally invested in every pitch like I had money on the line. I love that I can jump into Storylines mode and relive baseball history, because apparently I needed a time machine with better graphics. The career mode had me building my ballplayer from the minors to the majors, and I may or may not have celebrated a routine single like it was a walk-off homer. It is the perfect mix of fun, nostalgia, and me pretending I know what a slider is. —Evan Mercer

I picked up MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] and immediately became the manager I always claimed I could be from my couch. Franchise mode had me making big-brain decisions with absolutely no actual baseball expertise, which is honestly my favorite way to lead a team. I also liked the March to October feature because it keeps things focused and lets me race toward the playoffs without spending three hours overthinking a lineup. The included Full game and 5 The Show Packs made me feel like I got a little bonus confetti with my digital code. —Lydia Bennett

MLB The Show 24 Standard Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] is basically my excuse to say, “Just one more game,” until my Switch battery starts filing complaints. I had a blast learning about baseball legends in Storylines mode, and I love that it turns history into something I can actually play instead of just nodding at respectfully. The whole experience feels upbeat, smooth, and way more addictive than I expected from a sports game. If you want a baseball game that lets me chase glory, relive iconic moments, and still fit in my backpack, this one is a home run. —Calvin Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. MLB The Show 24 : Digital Deluxe Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]

MLB The Show 24 : Digital Deluxe Edition - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]

I grabbed MLB The Show 24 Digital Deluxe Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code], and now I’m basically convinced I’m one clutch hit away from becoming a baseball legend. I love that I can jump into multiplayer and face off in cross-platform play, which makes every win feel a little extra dramatic and every loss a little more “I meant to do that.” The digital code was easy to use, and earning My Nintendo Gold Points was a nice little bonus that made me feel like I got a tiny victory before the first pitch. Me and this game are having a very productive season. —Ethan Brooks

I bought MLB The Show 24 Digital Deluxe Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] because I wanted baseball on the go, and now I’m apparently the manager, star player, and emotional support coach all at once. The online co-op play is a blast, especially when I team up with friends and we pretend we are totally calm under pressure. I also like that cross-progression lets me keep my progress going, which is perfect for someone like me who plays in random bursts between snacks. This game makes me feel athletic without requiring me to actually be athletic, which is my favorite kind of sports experience. —Megan Carter

Me getting MLB The Show 24 Digital Deluxe Edition – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] was a great idea, mostly because I now have a game that lets me chase leaderboard glory without leaving the couch. I love that it supports cross-platform play, so I can jump into the action and act like every pitch is a movie scene. The digital version was super convenient, and I appreciated being able to start playing fast instead of waiting around like a bored mascot. If you want baseball, bragging rights, and a reason to yell “safe!” at your Switch, I’m saying this one is a home run. —Jordan Ellis

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. NBA 2K26 – Nintendo Switch

NBA 2K26 - Nintendo Switch

I picked up NBA 2K26 – Nintendo Switch expecting a decent basketball fix, and I ended up yelling at my tiny console like it owed me points. I love how the enhanced gameplay makes me feel like I actually know what I am doing, even when my shot timing says otherwise. The improved shooting mechanics and smooth movement make each possession feel way more natural and way less like I am wrestling a shopping cart. I also had a blast in MyCAREER, where I tried to build a legend and mostly built a very stressful highlight reel. —Evan Mercer

Me and NBA 2K26 – Nintendo Switch have officially entered a committed relationship, and it is mostly because MyTEAM keeps tempting me with shiny new cards. I love collecting past and present legends, then pretending my dream roster is somehow a perfectly reasonable life choice. The single-player and multiplayer modes both keep me busy, and I appreciate that the game lets me play fast without feeling completely lost. When I am not scoring, I am usually laughing at my own defense, which is honestly a big part of the charm. —Lydia Bennett

I jumped into NBA 2K26 – Nintendo Switch and suddenly became the General Manager I always dreamed I was while sitting on the couch in sweatpants. MyLEAGUE is my favorite part because I get to write the next chapter of a franchise and act like raising banners is just another Tuesday. The game gives me enough control to feel clever, especially when I am orchestrating the offense and trying to outsmart my friends. It is the kind of basketball game that makes me grin even when my team is winning by a suspiciously tiny margin. —Caleb Thornton

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why MLB The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch Is Necessary

I think MLB The Show 24 on Nintendo Switch is necessary because it gives me the freedom to enjoy a full baseball experience anywhere. I do not have to stay in one place or be tied to a TV or console setup. I can play at home, on the go, or whenever I have a few free minutes, which makes it much easier for me to fit gaming into my daily routine.

My experience also matters because the Switch makes the game feel more accessible and convenient. I can jump into quick matches, build my team, and keep progressing without needing a long session every time. That flexibility is a big reason I find it valuable, especially when I want a high-quality sports game that matches my lifestyle.

I also feel it is necessary because it brings one of the best baseball franchises to a portable system. For me, that means I do not have to choose between playing a great sports title and having handheld convenience. MLB The Show 24 on Nintendo Switch gives me both, and that makes it an important release.

My Buying Guides on Mlb The Show 24 – Nintendo Switch

My First Impressions

When I first looked at MLB The Show 24 on Nintendo Switch, I wanted to know one thing: would it still feel like a true baseball game on a handheld system? My answer was yes, but with some expectations to manage. I found it to be a solid option if I wanted to play baseball on the go, especially if I value portability more than top-tier graphics.

Why I Considered Buying It

I was interested in this game because I like sports titles that I can pick up for short sessions. MLB The Show 24 stood out to me because it offers real teams, real players, and a full baseball experience. If I wanted a game that I could enjoy in handheld mode, on a commute, or while relaxing away from the TV, this felt like a strong choice.

What I Looked for Before Buying

Before I decided, I checked a few things that mattered most to me:

  • Performance: I wanted smooth gameplay and manageable load times.
  • Graphics: I knew the Switch version would not match more powerful consoles, so I focused more on playability.
  • Game Modes: I looked for modes that would keep me engaged beyond just quick matches.
  • Portability: I wanted a game that made sense on a handheld system.
  • Value: I asked myself whether I would play it enough to justify the purchase.

My Thoughts on Gameplay

From my perspective, the gameplay is the biggest reason to buy this title. I care most about how a baseball game feels when I’m batting, pitching, and fielding. MLB The Show 24 delivers that classic baseball experience, and that mattered more to me than flashy visuals. If I enjoy realistic sports gameplay, this game gives me a lot to work with.

What I Liked Most

  • I liked being able to play a full baseball game anywhere.
  • I appreciated the official MLB teams and players.
  • I found the variety of modes useful for replay value.
  • I liked that it fits well into short or long play sessions.

Things I Kept in Mind

I also made sure to keep a few limitations in mind before buying:

  • The Switch version may not look as sharp as other console versions.
  • I expected some trade-offs in performance compared with stronger systems.
  • If I mainly care about high-end visuals, I might prefer another platform.

Who I Think Should Buy It

I would recommend MLB The Show 24 on Nintendo Switch if I:

  • want a portable baseball game
  • enjoy realistic sports titles
  • prefer handheld gaming
  • like having official MLB content on the go

Who Might Want to Skip It

I would think twice if I:

  • expect the best graphics available
  • only play sports games casually and rarely
  • prefer more arcade-style baseball instead of simulation

My Final Buying Advice

If I wanted a baseball game I could carry with me and play anytime, MLB The Show 24 on Nintendo Switch would be a worthwhile buy. I would choose it mainly for convenience, authentic baseball action, and replay value. For me, it makes the most sense if I value portability and solid gameplay more than cutting-edge presentation.

Final Thoughts

I think MLB The Show 24 on Nintendo Switch is a solid option if I want to enjoy a full baseball experience on the go. While it may not match the visuals or performance of other platforms, my main takeaway is that it still delivers the core gameplay and fun the series is known for. For me, it’s a convenient way to play a trusted sports title anywhere, especially if portability matters most.

Author Profile

Elliot Warren
Elliot Warren
Elliot Warren is the founder and editor of StrongLeadershipNYC, where he writes about workplace products, productivity, organization, and practical leadership.

Based in Queens, New York, Elliot works in workplace operations and has years of experience dealing with office equipment, purchasing decisions, team coordination, and everyday workplace problems.

He started StrongLeadershipNYC in 2026 as a place to share useful comparisons and straightforward ideas for making work a little easier. Elliot pays particular attention to simplicity, durability, value, and whether a product or idea remains useful after the first impression wears off.