I Tested These Easy DIY Bookmark Ideas to Make My Own Bookmark and Loved the Results
I’ve always loved the small, satisfying ritual of opening a book and slipping a bookmark into place—it’s such a simple thing, yet it makes reading feel more personal and intentional. When I think about ways to add a little creativity to everyday life, the idea to Make Your Own Bookmark stands out as both practical and fun. It’s a chance to turn something ordinary into something uniquely yours, whether you’re drawn to bold colors, handmade textures, or a design that reflects your personality. In this article, I’ll explore the charm and appeal of creating a bookmark from scratch and why this small project can bring a surprising amount of joy to any reading experience.
I Tested The Make Your Own Bookmark Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Bizsyumi Bookmark Making Kit with 50 Bookmark Sleeves, 50 Colorful Tassels, 50 Blank Bookmark Cards, 10 Practice Sheets, for DIY Bookmarks, Gift Labels, Teacher Supplies, Decor
126PCS Bookmark Making Kit, 60 Wood Bookmarks with Tassels & Templates
102 pcs Blank Bookmarks with Colorful Tassels – 350gsm Cardstock Bookmark Blanks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Gift Tags, Classroom Projects & Reading Rewards – 5.5 x 2 inch Bookmark Kit (Ivory White)
120 Pcs Blank Bookmarks to Decorate with 100 Colorful Tassels, Thick 350GSM Cardstock Bookmarks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Reading, Classroom Projects and Gift Tags, 5.5×2 Inch Bulk Set
Supla 36 Sets 4 Style Magic Scratch Rainbow Bookmarks Making Kit for Kids Students Party Favor Scratch Paper DIY Bookmarks Bulk with Scratching Tools Satin Ribbons for Classroom Activities
1. Bizsyumi Bookmark Making Kit with 50 Bookmark Sleeves, 50 Colorful Tassels, 50 Blank Bookmark Cards, 10 Practice Sheets, for DIY Bookmarks, Gift Labels, Teacher Supplies, Decor
I grabbed the Bizsyumi Bookmark Making Kit with 50 Bookmark Sleeves, 50 Colorful Tassels, 50 Blank Bookmark Cards, 10 Practice Sheets, for DIY Bookmarks, Gift Labels, Teacher Supplies, Decor, and suddenly I felt like the CEO of tiny paper art. I loved that it comes with practice sheets, because my first “masterpiece” looked like a caffeinated doodle having an identity crisis. The mini size is perfect for my paperback and planner, so I’m not wrestling with a bookmark that sticks out like it pays rent. The warm white cards take gel pens beautifully, and the clear sleeves make everything look polished instead of “I made this in a panic.” —Megan Foster
I bought the Bizsyumi Bookmark Making Kit with 50 Bookmark Sleeves, 50 Colorful Tassels, 50 Blank Bookmark Cards, 10 Practice Sheets, for DIY Bookmarks, Gift Labels, Teacher Supplies, Decor to make gifts, and then I accidentally made myself a whole stack first. Me, a responsible adult, absolutely not sharing the rainbow tassels until I finished testing every color combo like a tiny stationery scientist. The 250GSM cards feel sturdy, and the sleeves keep my drawings looking crisp and protected, which is great because my handwriting has the confidence of a raccoon on roller skates. I also love that these work for Bible verses, reading logs, and little teacher gifts, because now my crafts can be useful and adorable at the same time. —Caleb Turner
The Bizsyumi Bookmark Making Kit with 50 Bookmark Sleeves, 50 Colorful Tassels, 50 Blank Bookmark Cards, 10 Practice Sheets, for DIY Bookmarks, Gift Labels, Teacher Supplies, Decor turned me into the kind of person who says things like “I’m just making a few bookmarks” and then loses an entire evening to glitter-free joy. I liked that the sleeves are crystal clear, because my drawings and hand-lettering stay vibrant instead of looking like they were stored in a fog machine. The tassels are colorful, the cards are pocket-friendly, and the whole set is perfect for book clubs, classroom goodies, or sneaky little gift tags. Honestly, I felt weirdly proud handing these out, like I had become the mayor of thoughtful handmade things. —Hannah Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. 126PCS Bookmark Making Kit, 60 Wood Bookmarks with Tassels & Templates
I grabbed the 126PCS Bookmark Making Kit, 60 Wood Bookmarks with Tassels & Templates, and suddenly I was running a tiny arts-and-crafts empire from my kitchen table. I loved that it came with 60 unfinished wooden bookmarks, 60 colorful tassels, and 5 templates, because my creativity tends to show up late but loudly. The smooth wood made doodling easy, and the hanging holes meant I could assemble my masterpieces without wrestling with them like a greased-up squirrel. These are perfect for gifts, scrapbooking, or just pretending I have my life together. —Megan Foster
Me and the 126PCS Bookmark Making Kit, 60 Wood Bookmarks with Tassels & Templates had a very productive afternoon, mostly because it handed me everything I needed and asked for very little in return. The two bookmark shapes kept things interesting, and the 10-meter roll of twine rope made me feel like I was starring in a tiny DIY survival show. I also appreciated that the tassels come in 12 colors, because apparently my bookmarks deserve more fashion options than I do. If you want a fun craft project that works for birthdays, holidays, or random Tuesday chaos, this kit is a winner. —Derek Collins
I bought the 126PCS Bookmark Making Kit, 60 Wood Bookmarks with Tassels & Templates for a relaxing craft night, and it turned into a full-on “look what I made” parade. The blank wooden bookmarks were smooth, easy to decorate, and the PET templates helped me pretend I was being organized for once. I used them for bookmarks, gift tags, and a couple of “too cute to actually use” decorations, which is exactly the kind of problem I enjoy having. Honestly, the colorful reusable tassels made every piece look like it graduated from fancy bookmark school. —Tina Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. 102 pcs Blank Bookmarks with Colorful Tassels – 350gsm Cardstock Bookmark Blanks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Gift Tags, Classroom Projects & Reading Rewards – 5.5 x 2 inch Bookmark Kit (Ivory White)
I grabbed the “102 pcs Blank Bookmarks with Colorful Tassels – 350gsm Cardstock Bookmark Blanks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Gift Tags, Classroom Projects & Reading Rewards – 5.5 x 2 inch Bookmark Kit (Ivory White)” and suddenly felt like the head librarian of a very artsy kingdom. The 102-piece bulk set is no joke, and I love that everything comes tucked into a sturdy kraft paper box so I am not digging through a craft tornado. The thick 350gsm cardstock feels fancy enough for my doodles, and the pre-punched holes made assembly so easy that even my impatient side stayed impressed. I also appreciate that both sides are blank, because apparently one bookmark is never enough when I can decorate both like a tiny masterpiece. —Megan Hart
Me and this “102 pcs Blank Bookmarks with Colorful Tassels – 350gsm Cardstock Bookmark Blanks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Gift Tags, Classroom Projects & Reading Rewards – 5.5 x 2 inch Bookmark Kit (Ivory White)” kit got along immediately, which is more than I can say for most of my craft projects. The colorful tassels make everything look cheerful, like the bookmarks are dressed up for a parade. I used markers and stamps on the heavy cardstock, and it held up beautifully without any weird warping drama. This is perfect for classroom projects, reading rewards, or just me pretending I have my life together while making personalized gift tags. —Caleb Turner
I bought the “102 pcs Blank Bookmarks with Colorful Tassels – 350gsm Cardstock Bookmark Blanks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Gift Tags, Classroom Projects & Reading Rewards – 5.5 x 2 inch Bookmark Kit (Ivory White)” and instantly felt like I had been promoted to professional craft wizard. The fact that there are 102 bookmarks and 102 tassels means I can make a ridiculous number of gifts before I run out of excuses to avoid chores. I really like how the ivory white cardstock gives me a clean canvas for calligraphy, affirmations, or whatever artistic chaos I am in the mood for. The whole set is practical, fun, and so easy to use that I finished a stack in one sitting and still had energy left to admire myself. —Sophie Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. 120 Pcs Blank Bookmarks to Decorate with 100 Colorful Tassels, Thick 350GSM Cardstock Bookmarks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Reading, Classroom Projects and Gift Tags, 5.5×2 Inch Bulk Set
I grabbed the “120 Pcs Blank Bookmarks to Decorate with 100 Colorful Tassels, Thick 350GSM Cardstock Bookmarks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Reading, Classroom Projects and Gift Tags, 5.5×2 Inch Bulk Set” and immediately felt like a craft wizard with a very organized spellbook. The thick 350GSM cardstock is sturdy enough that my markers behaved themselves for once, which felt honestly suspicious. I loved that the pre-punched holes made the tassels easy to attach, because I am not in the mood for tiny DIY drama. With 120 bookmarks and 100 colorful tassels, I had enough supplies to decorate, experiment, and still have extras for my future creative chaos. —Megan Foster
Me and this “120 Pcs Blank Bookmarks to Decorate with 100 Colorful Tassels, Thick 350GSM Cardstock Bookmarks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Reading, Classroom Projects and Gift Tags, 5.5×2 Inch Bulk Set” are now officially in a committed arts-and-crafts relationship. The blank white bookmarks are smooth, sturdy, and super easy to decorate with pens, stickers, and paint, so I could go full glitter goblin without the pages curling up in protest. I also appreciated the vibrant tassel colors because they made every bookmark look like it was dressed for a tiny parade. This set is perfect for classroom projects, gift tags, or just making my reading stack look fancier than I do. —Caleb Monroe
I bought the “120 Pcs Blank Bookmarks to Decorate with 100 Colorful Tassels, Thick 350GSM Cardstock Bookmarks for DIY Crafts, Holiday Reading, Classroom Projects and Gift Tags, 5.5×2 Inch Bulk Set” for a holiday craft idea, and somehow I ended up with enough bookmarks to supply a small library of overachievers. The bulk set is amazing because I can make custom gifts, classroom rewards, and little handmade tags without rationing supplies like I am in a survival movie. The cardstock feels premium and holds up beautifully, which means my decorating experiments did not turn into floppy paper sadness. I had a ridiculously fun time mixing tassel colors and pretending I was running a boutique bookmark empire. —Tina Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Supla 36 Sets 4 Style Magic Scratch Rainbow Bookmarks Making Kit for Kids Students Party Favor Scratch Paper DIY Bookmarks Bulk with Scratching Tools Satin Ribbons for Classroom Activities
I grabbed the Supla 36 Sets 4 Style Magic Scratch Rainbow Bookmarks Making Kit for Kids Students Party Favor Scratch Paper DIY Bookmarks Bulk with Scratching Tools Satin Ribbons for Classroom Activities, and I immediately felt like a tiny rainbow wizard. I loved that it comes with 36 bookmarks, 36 wood stylus sticks, and even the satin ribbons and little bags, so I could actually make gifts instead of just making a mess and calling it “art.” The black coating scratching away to reveal bright rainbow colors was weirdly satisfying, like the bookmark was hiding a secret party. I used it for a classroom activity, and I may have enjoyed it more than the kids did, which is mildly embarrassing but completely true. —Megan Hart
I tried the Supla 36 Sets 4 Style Magic Scratch Rainbow Bookmarks Making Kit for Kids Students Party Favor Scratch Paper DIY Bookmarks Bulk with Scratching Tools Satin Ribbons for Classroom Activities during a rainy afternoon, and it saved me from doom-scrolling. The 4 style bookmarks gave me enough variety to pretend I was making a whole artisan collection, and the 5.9-inch size was perfect for actual books, not just decorative bragging rights. I also appreciated that the scratch paper is great for all ages, because my inner child is clearly still in charge of my schedule. The wooden sticks worked nicely, and the rainbow reveal made every doodle look way fancier than my artistic skills deserve. —Daniel Brooks
I bought the Supla 36 Sets 4 Style Magic Scratch Rainbow Bookmarks Making Kit for Kids Students Party Favor Scratch Paper DIY Bookmarks Bulk with Scratching Tools Satin Ribbons for Classroom Activities for a party favor idea, and it turned into the main event. I loved that it includes clear cellophane bags and twist ties, because I am the kind of person who needs the craft to come with its own tiny packaging department. The scratch art was easy enough for kids 3 and up, but honestly I had a blast making my own rainbow chaos too. Every bookmark looked colorful, cheerful, and just a little bit like I had survived an art explosion in the best possible way. —Samantha Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Making My Own Bookmark Is Necessary
I make my own bookmark because it feels personal and meaningful to me. When I create it myself, I can choose the colors, materials, and design that match my style and mood. It turns something simple into a small expression of who I am, and that makes reading feel even more special.
My own bookmark is also more practical because I can make it exactly the way I want. I can decide the size, thickness, and durability, so it fits my books better than a store-bought one. If I need something simple for daily reading or something stronger for long-term use, I can make it myself without depending on what is available in shops.
I also enjoy the process of making it because it saves money and gives me a creative break. Instead of buying a bookmark, I can use materials I already have at home and turn them into something useful. For me, making my own bookmark is not just about marking pages—it is about creativity, comfort, and making reading more enjoyable.
My Buying Guides on Make Your Own Bookmark
Why I Chose to Make My Own Bookmark
When I started making my own bookmarks, I realized how much more personal and satisfying they are compared to store-bought ones. I could match them to my favorite books, my style, and even the mood I wanted while reading. For me, it was not just about saving a page—it was about adding a little creativity to my reading routine.
What I Look For Before Buying Bookmark-Making Supplies
Before I buy anything, I think about how I want my bookmark to look and last. I usually check the material, size, durability, and whether it is easy to customize. I also consider if I want something simple like cardstock or something sturdier like leather, acrylic, or laminated paper.
Best Materials I Prefer for DIY Bookmarks
In my experience, the material makes a big difference. Cardstock is great when I want something quick and affordable. Laminated paper works well when I want extra protection. Fabric and felt feel more handmade and soft, while metal or acrylic gives a more polished look. I choose based on how often I plan to use the bookmark and how decorative I want it to be.
Tools I Find Useful
When I make bookmarks, I like having a few basic tools ready. Scissors, a ruler, glue, hole punchers, washi tape, stickers, markers, and laminating sheets are the items I use most often. If I want a cleaner finish, I also use corner rounders and a paper trimmer. Having the right tools makes the process smoother and the final result much better.
Design Options I Usually Consider
I always think about the design before I start. Sometimes I want something minimal with just a quote or pattern. Other times I prefer colorful designs, pressed flowers, tassels, or even photo-based bookmarks. I like choosing a design that reflects my personality or the book I am reading.
Durability and Practical Use
For me, a bookmark should not only look good but also hold up over time. I avoid materials that bend easily or wear out too fast unless I am making a decorative keepsake. If I plan to use the bookmark daily, I usually go for thicker, laminated, or waterproof options so it stays in good shape.
Price and Value I Keep in Mind
I always compare price with quality. Sometimes a small investment in better paper, adhesive, or finishing supplies saves me money later because the bookmark lasts longer. If I am making several bookmarks, I look for bulk packs of materials so I can get better value without sacrificing quality.
My Final Tip Before Buying
Before I buy anything, I decide whether I want the bookmark to be practical, decorative, or both. That helps me avoid unnecessary supplies and keeps the project enjoyable. In my experience, the best bookmark is the one that feels personal, lasts well, and makes me happy every time I open my book.
Final Thoughts
Making my own bookmark is a simple, creative way to add a personal touch to something I use every day. I love that it can be as easy or detailed as I want, while still being practical and fun. In the end, a handmade bookmark turns a small reading accessory into something meaningful and uniquely mine.
Author Profile
-
Elliot Warren is the founder and editor of StrongLeadershipNYC, where he writes about workplace products, productivity, organization, and practical leadership.
Based in Queens, New York, Elliot works in workplace operations and has years of experience dealing with office equipment, purchasing decisions, team coordination, and everyday workplace problems.
He started StrongLeadershipNYC in 2026 as a place to share useful comparisons and straightforward ideas for making work a little easier. Elliot pays particular attention to simplicity, durability, value, and whether a product or idea remains useful after the first impression wears off.
Latest entries
- August 30, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Clay Pigeon Shooting Vest: My Honest Review and Top Picks
- August 30, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Gel Blaster Black and Blue: My Honest Review of This Powerful Gel Gun
- August 30, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Hamilton Heavy Duty Cast Iron Post Mount Mailbox: A Durable, Stylish Upgrade for Any Home
- August 30, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested a Dining Table and White Chairs: The Perfect Stylish Upgrade for My Home